Benedict Takes Over the World

Videogames are a waste of time.

I mean, they are!

Right? I mean- look, my usual audience would disagree with you at length, I would disagree with you at length, but it's a hard conclusion to escape.

I'm writing this month primarily to an audience of Inkhaven readers, and these people are way too cool for videogames. These are, on the whole, freakishly smart people who take their academic disciplines very seriously and have decided to spend their time working as hard as possible on the most difficult and most important problems they can find. I went to a speedfriending event where my first question for every new person I met was "what do you write about?" and I shit you not five people in a row answered "AI safety", without hesitation. They write like they're running out of time, like they're running out of time.

Videogames are a form of entertainment, and they're an overwhelmingly lowbrow form of entertainment. Many arguments have been marshalled against this reputation, and theoretically you can create interactive experiences that intellectually enrich the player, but like. Y'know. Pick a random videogame. If it has a story at all, you got lucky. If it has themes, you got really lucky. If it says something unique and coherent about those themes, you need to start buying lottery tickets.

So if you're a very intellectually serious person, you don't need to be convinced that videogames are a waste of time. You've probably used your eyes at some point and noticed very strong evidence in that direction.

Have you wondered why, though?

Well, it's usually because they're doing it on purpose. They want to waste your time. And their audience, for some reason, wants their time to be wasted.

If you haven't spent a lot of time reading games journalism and analyzing the marketing, you might be unaware that games, as a general rule, advertise the number of hours they will take to play as a selling point.

No, I'm not kidding. You'll see ad blurbs breathlessly informing you that this game has 80 hours of content! 200 hours! Infinite replayability, even! They want players to know this, so that they will be enticed by the larger number of hours the game will demand of them!

You don't see this with movies! If you check the runtime of a movie and it's more than four hours, you're reconsidering watching that movie unless you have a really good reason to expect it will be good in spite of its runtime. If a TV show has twenty seasons, you can bet it ran out of ideas like ten of them ago. If a book has too many pages in it, the binding starts falling apart. Nobody wants anything else to be long for the sake of being long.

This is categorically crazypants. How did we get here?

Unfortunately, everything about the medium kind of pushes in this direction, if you think about it. It's reinforced in every part of making and selling the damn things. We're fucked.

You might be tempted to think of it purely as a value thing. That's certainly what the average gamer has been conditioned to think! An hour of playing a game is fun, right? You want more of those. As many of them per dollar spent as possible. If you spent $20 on a 200-hour game, that's ten hours of fun per one dollar! Movie tickets could never!

But... yeah, movie tickets could never. No one tries to get the theatergoer in the door by promising a 10-hour movie for the cost of a 2-hour movie. People wouldn't accept that. TV shows released in their entirety on streaming platforms do worse than shows released serially a little bit at a time. Why doesn't the same value proposition apply?

No, the first real thing to note is that games take way more effort to make compared to any other medium. They need visuals- dozens to hundreds to thousands of bespoke pieces of art, illustrating both characters and environments. And there's no shortcuts there- unlike film and TV, you can't point a camera at something happening in reality and capture that. If you want to depict something that happens in physical reality, such as a character navigating a 3D environment, you need to create elaborately-rigged 3D models, which are more labor-intensive to produce than any painting or photograph. You need sound effects, you need music, you need writing, you need lots and lots of software engineering- you need it all, on top of the unique and poorly-understood art of game design. These little shits are obligate gesamtkunstwerks.

(Low-budget solo projects have to compromise massively on all these things. if you're not some kind of insane multitalented savant, you're probably only good at one or two of these things- so typically a game takes a large and multidisciplinary team to put together. It's extremely rare to find a singular author who doesn't fall down embarrassingly on at least one of these many aspects.)

So any given minute of a specific thing happening in a videogame takes this massive amount of work to produce. How, then, do we get a state of affairs where games are hundreds of hours long and there is demand for that?

Well, if one minute of a specific thing happening takes X man-hours to make, what if you just loop that one minute a hundred times and call that an artistic statement? Now you've got a feature-length film, right?

Games have to make heavy use of repetition to be remotely cost-effective to make at all. If there's something compelling to the player about having their avatar jump on a Goomba, well, you're leaving money on the ground if you don't give them the chance to do it a bunch more times. How many more times? Well, you had to pay a 3D artist some amount of money to model the Goomba, and an animator to show the player jumping, and a foley artist to make a "bwoop" sound when it gets squished, and a programmer to make the goomba load in and walk at you and die. That's not zero dollars. So, like... y'know, repeat it until the player gets bored! Then you got your money's worth.

That's not... natural, is it? In writing, you're supposed to omit needless words. Kill your darlings. Let the rivers run red with editor's ink, cutting down what you have to get your point across with as little work as possible. You want your ideas in the reader's head with the minimum required verbiage. I should've deleted that last sentence, even, for not saying anything the previous one didn't. How did we get so turned around?

Well- having every moment of your game be something bespoke and intentional normally doesn't work. Like I said- it's expensive! If you can use a preexisting art asset or game object or mechanic to produce the intended effect instead of making a new one, you do. Strategic recontextualization of actions and images has a huge effect on the cost of production. In games, you don't omit needless words- you omit needless game development.

Imagine trying to write a book in a world where the printer charges you a cent per unique word used in the text. If you need too many different words to tell your story, you will not have enough money to print the book. There's a hard limit where the cost of printing the book exceeds the amount of money the reader is willing to pay- and if you can get your unique wordcount down as low as possible, you can make way more on the marginal book sale.

In such a world, what does it tell you when a book has 80 pages in it and costs $5? That's impressive, isn't it? They're selling you 80 whole pages of book, and only used 500 words of the English language to write it! And maybe you worry that the book is a little repetitive and can only say so much with so few words, but you can check reviews to see if it's good anyway, and if it is, I mean, that's a steal! And it'd be even more impressive if you could write 200 pages for the same cost, right? How about a book with infinite pages?! That sounds too good to be true, but maybe there's something to it...!

The more complex the idea you're trying to express, the more expensive it is to produce, and so the pressure is always to simplify and simplify and simplify. The big publishers would love to be able to sell a book that consisted of nothing but 1000 pages of the word "the"- and maybe no one would buy that, but maybe 1000 pages of the word "sex"? How can we get people to pay entire-book prices for the simplest stories with the fewest ideas?

That's basically the pressure working against games as an intellectually serious medium. Publishers have conditioned their audience to value meaningless metrics- to want their time wasted, because the more time they can waste, the further their dollar has gone.

I refuse to accept this framing! I have shit to do! Playtime is a cost!

← All posts